Thursday, September 30, 2010

Re-doing a shot: getting rid of the mental block

So how many of you can relate to the poor animator in the pic?

I can!

Like every other animator out there, when I was starting out, I used to face this enormous overwhelming challenge of redoing shots. “What the heck! Now I gotta change all my animation that I almost starved myself to create??” That thought would creep me out (it still does)! However with time and practice, when I somehow pulled this fear out of me (at least to quite an extent), I realized that wasn’t so scary after all! "Maybe it was just me and my silly mental block! Doh!" I concluded.

But nope! It’s not just me! A recent interaction with a friend fairly new in this field made me realise that it’s not as easy to remove that ‘mental block’ as I thought. Much of the lot seems so attached to their work and forgiving of their mistakes that any changes suggested could as well mean murder!

Truth is, the real animation world out there isn’t so forgiving. If a shot needs changes, it needs changes. Get that right or get fired!

The first thing you gotta do is lose the love for your shot. It’s okay to appreciate that you have an ability to create something of this caliber, but kindly keep it to that. ANY shot (I repeat ANY shot) has the potential to be better. A very talented friend of mine once said “An animator never really finishes his work, he simply surrenders!” So unless you’re married to your shot, lose the love.

There’s another factor why animators fear incorporating changes: LOW CONFIDENCE. This applies fairly to the newbies. They don’t exactly love their shots, they know there are problems in them, but at the same time they just can’t seem to gather enough confidence to make changes, fearing it might end up looking worse.

In either case, it’s all a matter of thinking. You need to mentally prepare yourself when you work on a shot, that you might be asked to make changes. And when someone does suggest changes, you should tell yourself over and over again “Yeah I need to change that” rather than “Oh man now I gotta change that??” The former thought process creates a certain uneasiness within you and subconsciously you feel restless until you finally incorporate those changes. It also prevents you from being complacent. Okay I agree it’s definitely human to think "Oh man now I gotta change that??". What makes the difference is how fast you switch to "Yeah I need to change that".

You need to make a start someday. This mainly applies to students and people who are learning on their own. It’s better to get used to redoing shots as early as possible when there’s no one looming over your head with a deadline sword. That way at least you’ll get some practice and later on actually perform better in production when there is someone looming over your head with a deadline sword. Because then you will have gotten used to making changes in your shots rather than freaking out saying “What the heck! Changes?? Nobody taught me that in school!” You become flexible.

Let me give you my own example of how I went about getting rid of that fear.

I am definitely not someone who loves his shots. I was more of the not-confident type. I remember in my animation school (Takshaa), when I was in my first semester (on learning basics), I did two shots as assignments (ball-box, and ballman-ball interaction). I was suggested some major changes to improve them. But I was pensive! “Who’s gonna go through all those graphs again?” Eventually I didn’t make any changes thinking I’ll get used to redoing shots later with time.

I went to the second semester and did some walk/run cycles. Once again changes were suggested. Once again I got pensive, thinking I would incorporate changes in my next assignment, even though all the while knowing that those changes are needed. And sure enough I didn’t make any.

Then I did a jump. Changes suggested again. Me pensive again. Me thinking again “Okay next time for sure”. But this time I had an additional thought “I can’t keep procrastinating like this.” That’s all it took to break the ice. Those 6 words! That thought process created the required uneasiness in me.

So I chose a day and sat down to make changes And yes, it was tough! I hesitated to even touch the controllers. It was a struggle all the way, first to get rid of that mental block, second to actually change the animation. It wasn’t easy also because initially the changed action wasn’t really looking good (animation principle wise), and plus my previous saved version was always there tempting me to give up and be complacent with it!

I still kept going, and finally one fine day it started to look good, or I dare say, even better than the previous version! Below are the videos to show what I mean.

Original version

Changed version (improvised ending)

Okay agreed, the animation isn’t really all that great when I look at it now, but the important thing is, I overcame that fear! It gave me a sense of accomplishment! And that’s when it hit me: changes aren't really that scary! It completely 'changed' my perspective!

And since then, I’ve been on a roll! Removing this fear even made me grow as an animator. I’ve happily welcomed changes in my shots and each time I incorporate them I see that they really push the piece further.

A very prominent example I can give you is when I was blocking out a shot for the 11SC July 2010 contest. Changes were suggested to go for a completely new acting choice and set up, and further below is what it finally looked like.

Original version

Changed version

So yeah it’s really all in the head! You can’t let that simple mental block (which isn’t as scary as you think anyway) get in your way of improvement. Try it once and you'll see for yourselves. Once you get rid of the fear, you’re already halfway there. The other half, where you actually make the changed animation look good or better, is only a matter of time.


Anonymous said...

Hey Dapun,
Thanks a tonne for taking out the time to share with us your experiences and the little things(that people usually tend to forget) that helped you evolve into the artist and animator you presently are.Not only is this very nicely written,your taking the trouble of linking videos and providing/mentioning examples/past incidents helped even more.Hope to see many more such posts from you in the future.
Love the illustration too. :D

Adil dekate said...

Hey buddy... I really felt what you mean .. Cant help reading it twice.. coz M inspired :)

Best wishes !!


Prasad said...

Wow that was some insightful post ! ...yeah it sometimes become too hard to start all over again ...but once you are in you are in ! or re-work it's addicting after-all. Also to support your last para, i remember what our sir use to say work of an artist is bad, he may grow to find his work of less caliber later in his life, so if you feel some of you old work is not good enough be sure that you have grown and are better know ! ...just remembered it ! ...and thanks again for this cool post.

Asif said...

Excellent Post!!! keep it up bro.

chandrashekhar r said...

Nice one!

Mitali P said...

woah, that was awesome .. and helpful

preetham.g.raj said...

well.. time to start that long and hard journey of getting tat fear outta me now. wish me luck. thanks man!

Dapoon said...

Thanks guys! Glad to know it helped! :)

Anonymous said...

hi! thanks for posting this! im still learning animation in college, and the lecturer always tells us to change/make improvements on our assignments, so...we kinda have to make them or else our grades will not be very good and we get that 'im not happy you didnt heed my suggestion' aura from him when its time for critique and omysoulimrambling > < but yea, my whole problem is the same as yours was-the low self confidence in your work. Like you feel you dont have the skill to make the changes in the shot; so inturn your animation tends to get suckier. im so scared im not cut out for animating and i love it so much. must strive to change!

Adil dekate said...

My 1st comment (me sitting at home ) :P Hey buddy... I really felt what you mean .. Cant help reading it twice.. coz M inspired :)

Best wishes !!


Now I feel like What THe hell was that comment..Not fair..

Now when I m Doing my Jump assignment and went through your article . Now I know what you say By getting rid of that mental block.. I feel whatever changes you do Even if You feel might ruin your piece...It so helps..Any changes in your animation Just makes it better..I've felt that :D

So here's to CHANGES :D